Hats off! Along the street there comes A blare of bugles, a ruffle of drums,
A flash of color beneath the sky: Hats off! The flag is passing by." -- Henry Holcomb BennettJosh Parsons is not happy with the poor design of some of the world's nation flags. "Some are good, some are bad. Some countries have clearly taken care in the choice of colours, layout, and design. Others have been lazy, stolen the flags of their neighbours, or just designed flags that are clearly supposed to cause pain to those who look at them." Rather than stew in silence, he did something about it. He ranked all of the flags of the world and gave them a score based on their overall aesthetic value.
In his Flags of the World Given Letter Grades he gives high marks for simple design with a pleasant choice of colors. Ugly flags, with garish colors are sent to the corner with a dunce cap.
What does any of this have to do with maps? Parson's Rule 2: Do not put a map of your country on your flag. "When someone is travelling around your country, where do you think they will look if they need a map? Bzzt! No, they won't look at the flag." The worst offender is Cyprus. "Quite apart from the total uselessness of having a map on your flag, it really shows that a country hasn't gone to any effort if that's the best they can think of." While Cyprus has a distinctive shape, so do many other countries... but they can do better. Flags should be iconic, not literal. Grade D
He gives kudos to the nation of Gambia. "Great design and colour choice. Also represents the geography of the country (without being a map)." Grade A+
Gambia is a tiny nation hugging either side of the Gambia River, but surrouned by the nation of Senegal. The map design suggests this, without being too obvious. Clever map design.Thanks to Gadling for bringing this to my attention, here and here.
Posts
But...the flag of cyprus is attractive, unique and instantly recognisable. It might not be the most original thing out there, but it does stand out amongst other national flags.
ReplyDeleteThere are also advantages of having your map on your flag, suppose your people are divided and can't agree on a national symbol like the Cypriots of the 1960's (and today)? Aren't the ideas of loyalty to one's country (it's right there on the flag, after all) and peace amongst its people (that's an olive branch) enough for a flag? I think it's an attractive flag, that's simple to draw, has national symbolism, is unique amongst other national flags and rises above the Cypriot ties to both Greece and Turkey effectively.
I wouldn't say I love this flag, but I think it's better than the proposed tricolour even though it is a particularly nice example of a tricolour.
Maps on flags are fine with me.
s a Cartophile, I cannot help but agree that all maps are good... :-) I think Josh Parsons is a bit harsh on the whole "graven images" thing.
ReplyDeleteI look forward to seeing what sort of grade Michael5000 will give it when he gets to the "Cy"s